With oil near $100 and wages up 3.1%, the Fed is tightening against an energy shock
The Fed calls growth strong and productivity strong, yet two officials want a hike. The data points to energy, not wages, as the pressure, and that complicates what rate increases can fix.
Put three of the latest US data points side by side and they do not describe a classic wage-driven inflation. Average hourly earnings rose 3.1% over the 12 months to October, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. The last annual inflation reading, for September, was 3.7%. And WTI crude is trading just above $100 a barrel, up about 78% so far this year.
The Fed raised rates in September, held on October 28, and markets expect another increase in December. The question is what a rate rise can do when the pressure appears to come from fuel.
What the Fed’s own words imply
The October statement says activity is expanding strongly, with “robust capital investment and strong productivity growth”, and that job gains have kept pace with the workforce. About inflation it says only that it “remains elevated”. The full statement shows a 10-2 vote to hold at 3-3/4 to 4 percent, with Governor Lisa Cook and Cleveland Fed President Beth Hammack preferring a quarter-point hike.
Strong productivity matters here. When output per hour grows quickly, a firm can pay more without raising prices. Wage growth of 3.1% sits below the 3.7% inflation rate, so by my arithmetic real pay is falling by about 0.6 percentage points a year, though the two figures cover slightly different periods.
That is not the profile of a wage-price spiral. It looks more like households absorbing a price shock.
The energy trail in the CPI
The October consumer price report is consistent with that reading. Per StockAnalysis’s summary, energy prices rose 5.2% in September and 0.7% in October. Headline CPI rose 0.6% in September and 0.4% in October. Core, which strips out food and energy, rose 0.3% in August, September and October.
ABC News adds that gasoline rose more than 9% in September, and that the national average pump price had fallen below $4 by November 9, per GasBuddy, after oil declines following the midterms. That fall is not yet in any official index.
Compare the two monthly paths. Headline swung from 0.6% to 0.4% as energy eased. Core stayed flat at 0.3%. A flat 0.3% a month is about 3.7% if it persists for a year, by my arithmetic from compounding, which is near the September annual headline. So core is not cooling, but it is also not accelerating.
The case for tightening anyway
The sources give the hawks real material. Jobs rose by 165,000 in October against a 12-month average of 48,000, unemployment fell to 4.1%, and the two prior months were revised up by 84,000 combined, BLS reports. The labour market is not weakening.
Chair Kevin Warsh said inflation “has been running above the Committee’s objective for close to 6 years.” A committee that has missed its target for that long has reason to worry about expectations settling at a higher level, whatever caused the latest jump. Governor Christopher Waller, per StockAnalysis, said a core reading around 0.3% or higher would warrant considering a 50-basis-point increase in December. The October core reading was 0.3%.
After the CPI, ABC put CME FedWatch odds at about 82% for a quarter-point hike. That is a market expectation, not a decision.
What a hike can and cannot reach
Higher policy rates work mainly through demand: borrowing costs rise, spending slows, and price pressure eases. They have little direct effect on a global crude price. If oil is the main source of the current inflation, a hike treats the second-round effects (energy costs spreading to other prices and to expectations) rather than the first.
The sources do not show how large those second-round effects are. Shelter, which rose 0.3% and made up more than 30% of the October increase, is not an energy item. The data cannot separate how much of core is energy pass-through and how much is demand.
The 10-year Treasury yield closed at 5.03% on October 28, according to StockAnalysis, so markets have already priced in some of the tightening. Whether the Fed adds to that in December depends on the November CPI, which arrives on December 10, one day after the meeting ends.
What to watch
Three readings would test this thesis. Gasoline prices in the November CPI show whether the fall below $4 reaches the index. Core goods and services show whether energy costs are spreading. And wage growth shows whether the 3.1% holds while real pay is negative.
If energy eases and core stays at 0.3%, the Fed will have raised rates against a shock that was already fading. If core accelerates, the case for the 50-basis-point move gets stronger. The October data fits both outcomes, and the sources do not say which one the committee expects.
Sources
- Federal Reserve: FOMC statement, October 28, 2026 federalreserve.gov
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics: The Employment Situation, October 2026 bls.gov
- StockAnalysis: Fed holds rates steady at 3.75% to 4.00% in a 10-2 vote stockanalysis.com
- StockAnalysis: US consumer prices rise 0.4% in October, above forecasts stockanalysis.com
- ABC News (via ABC7): Consumer prices increased 0.4% in October, higher than expected abc7news.com
This article is information, not investment, tax or legal advice. Figures come from the sources above and may have changed since publication.